Fleshman was last seen leaving her home heading toward Roanoke, Virginia. Here are eight truly bone-chilling unsolved crimes that will have you looking over your own shoulder. The flyer shared by the sheriffs office describes the first person of interest is described as a white male who would have been in his mid-20s and weighed 230-260 pounds at the time with a high, receding hairline and shoulder-length, stringy light brown hair and long sideburns. Results: 13 Record (s) Found. SJM: Or when they were caught, a man was convicted of 12 attempted abductions, and were not sure how many of those were actually coeds and how many were children because technically anyone under the age of 21 was not considered an adult, so they were kind of grouped together. If you are aware of a cold case that is not currently present on the website, please contact the investigating agency. She has a strawberry birthmark on the back of her neck. He had been murdered - tortured and shot." Dean was 14 at the time of the murder and knew Smith, who was a lifeguard at Watoga State Park during his summer break from West Virginia University. Holcomb reportedly has Alzheimers and may have headed toward Kentucky or Ohio. PUTNAM COUNTY, WV (WOWK) The Putnam County Sheriffs Office is reopening a murder cold case from 35 years ago. In Washington County, the sheriffs department has two cold case officers, Bruce Shuck and Jeff Seevers, but retired officers cant be similarly deputized in West Virginia, Stephens said. The cover of the new book "Murder on Staunton Road" by Charlie Ryan and Mitch Evans. Crutchleys sister was going to WVU at the time and was also a freshman, and so I think we can find a connection between her and Mared and Karen. From there, he went to a nearby house and, when the neighbor opened the door, Plants fell inside and onto the floor. Low around 35F. Updated: Oct 29, 2021 / 12:20 PM EDT PUTNAM COUNTY, WV (WOWK) - The Putnam County Sheriff's Office is reopening a murder cold case from 35 years ago. Her vehicle was found Feb. 25, 2022 near the TNT area of Mason County with her belongings inside. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. A fifth homicide was settled with a plea on May 6 when Adam Michael Barnhart, 18, of Weirton, admitted to killing Frank Tulock, 36, of Orchard Street on Sept. 8, 2013. Daniel was last seen at a Walgreens Pharmacy shortly around 12:30 p.m. July 22, 2014. Her body was later found along the St. Albans exit of I-64. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Foreman of the West Virginia State Police detachment near Princeton responded to a call at the Little General Store on Oakvale Road. Trending pages Danny Casolaro Sodder Family Paul Ferrell David Freeman Tim Good Martha Hinkle Darlene and Davida Ebmeier All items (8) # A B C D E F By J. JoAnn Plymale. Would you like to hear about the worst crime thats ever happened in Morgantown?, So I gave him the rundown on it, and he said, Do you want to make a podcast? Im like, Sure, whats a podcast? [laughs], And then, the article that I wrote did its rounds. The 208-page book is filled with one sensational crime after another such as the West Virginia University coed murder, the disappearance of the Sodder children in a Christmas Eve fire in 1945, the slaying of Montgomery city clerk Cathy Carroll, the Rand-Bailey mystery, the fatal shooting of a popular Beckley police officer. Ferbers vehicle, purse and belongings were found in Morgantown. Stephens cited an advantage departments in Ohio have over departments in West Virginia. That seemed to be just solely a WVU transportation problem because of the two campuses. On June 13, 1963, Wayne Pratt was found murdered in a gas station he operated along old Highway 41 between Neenah and Oshkosh. By Deirdre M. Enright. Four men were questioned, with one held in prison for suspicion of murder and then later released two years later, the case has since gone cold and so many . Two men were found and arrested, one of who said he was in the mine with Adkins around 2:30 a.m., but they had gotten separated. Water's Edge At Sandbridge Beach. We want justice, she was not only a great mother and sister she was the glue that held the family together, Key said. 10 The New Orleans Axeman1918-1919. Authorities say while at the bar, he went to the restroom but hasnt been seen or heard from since. Natasha Carter, also known as Alex was allegedly taken by her mother Susan Gail Carter, who may also be using the alias Susan Gail Carter Webb, during a custody dispute with Alexs father. They would give him Sodium Pentothal, and theyd prove that he didnt do it. He enjoyed farming, gardening, and front porch s. GF: One of the things that [Sarah] said, one of the first times we got together, was that Morgantown mustve been really scary in the 70s, and I thought, I grew up here, I didnt think it was scary at all. FROM HELL (2001) The Jack The Ripper case gets the big movie treatment in From Hell, a mystery horror film directed by the Hughes Brothers. The motorist parked in a nearby driveway and went back to help Leeper, flagging down cars and calling Mercer County 911. Anyone with information about the Petty case is encouraged to call the department, Stephens said. She was supposed to meet a relative to pick up money, but never called to tell them where to meet her. An interesting angle presented during the grand jury hearing was. Q: Anything else that you would like to add? The case of Nancy Probst's murder still remains unsolved. Can you bring your vape pen or e-cigarette on a plane? Barki, who took over as the countys chief law enforcement officer in January 2012 after serving for 11 years as an assistant prosecutor, said Brooke County is experiencing an unprecedented string of homicides-including five, possibly six, that have yet to come to trial. Stonewall Jackson died as a result of friendly fire in 1863 across the border in Clarksburg, West Virginia. Sgt. It was a human skull. Paramount/Getty Images. Parsons went missing from a barge in the Ohio River. His body was found halfway in and halfway out of a front door. March 7, 1997. Police continue to seek leads in regions unsolved homicides, Samantha Perry named CNHI Columnist of the Yea, Those Who Served War Museum reopens Monday, Red Devils fight back to snatch sectional crown, Richlands girls basketball coach arrested for assault following tournament incident, Local man faces 17 to 45 years in prison after sentencing on sexual assault and child porn, Virginia man facing second-degree murder after Maple Acres Road shooting, Tom Rife named All-SWD Girls Basketball Coach of the Year, Bramwell Corner Shop appearing on America's Best Restaurants, Coach behaving badly: Richlands players paid consequences for Rifes actions, Granada, Raleigh St. Cinemas, will fill void in AMC theaters closing, Officials to investigate incident between Richlands girls coach and spectator, Richlands 2D tournament incident receives national coverage, Mercer County Sheriff's Departmet warns public about new scam. Gwin-Stephens dropped her husband off at work at the Industrial park in Beckley and has not been seen or heard from since. West Virginia police were contacted by law enforcement officials in Camden, New Jersey after inmate Eugene Paul Clawson expressed that he was prepared to confess to a crime. A warrant for kidnapping was issued for Susan on Nov. 13, 2000. A Facebook was established, too, Justice for Judith Lynn Petty. Similarly, Montana has one of the lowest rates of unsolved murders as well. Vance was last seen in the 1000 block of Washington Avenue around 5 p.m. March 27, 2010. Loudoun County Sheriff's Office 803 Sycolin Road SE Leesburg, VA 20175 Phone: 703-777-0407 Fax: 703-771-5744 Mailing Address P.O. All of her personal belongings were left behind. He said Donald Bartz did not approve of his daughters older boyfriend and he forbid her from having a cell phone to call him. Another man, Dennis Powell, also went missing soon after. This source claims that one was killed and thrown from a truck in front of Corning Glass in 1979, and the . He had an involvement in the case. Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. According to authorities, she has a pegasus tattoo on her inner ankle with three or four stars above it and a butterfly on her chest which has scarring over it from a burn. And, as you know, around here, that doesnt. George Bragg holds his "Unsolved Murders" book. Thats why her son grew concerned about his mothers well-being after not hearing from her in more than a week. Victor was last seen playing with other children in the woods near Short Mountain. Jerry was last seen on his way to Boston and was involved in a minor crash in Clarksburg, West Virginia, but has not been seen or heard from since. There was one letter sent on April 8th and then another one mailed the 10th to correct people because whoever was writing thisat the time, they didnt know who was writing this. Get the Android Weather app from Google Play, Mortgage rates have little reason to fall in March, Ceremony held for new Jackson Co. solar titanium. In December 2021, the FBI announced a reward of $10K for information that leads to a resolution in the case. Geoffrey and S. James McLaughlin encourage folks to take a look at jewelry found in possession of John Brennan Crutchley to see if they look familiar. He was the one who was in charge of the PRT project, and he didnt say anything in testimony. He said police believe Castillo lived with Plants in Wellsburg sometime before his death, but its not known when or for how long. And, I dont know, I just got this idea in my head. Which is why Poiani keeps the story in the public eye every year around this time. The next unsolved mystery: November 24, 1971. Prosecutors maintained Carroll had arranged for the murder of Cathy Faye Carroll, his estranged wife, on April 22, 1986 at her home in Montgomery Heights. No one has seen her since. "This series is about the murder of Walter T. Smith in 1975," Dean said. In 2015, there were only 36 murders and non-negligent manslaughters in the entire state. Red retired as a machinist. All Rights Reserved. Besides all being shootings, little connects the eight unsolved homicides. According to a . The Oscars will air on ABC and can be streamed on ABC.com and the ABC app as well as Hulu + Live TV, YouTube TV, AT&T TV or FuboTV. Authorities received tips about sightings of Steptoe in Mercer and McDowell counties, but the information did not lead to him. Anyone with information regarding any of these cases is urged to contact the assigned detective at the contact information included in the summary, or by calling 304-357-0556. Sharp was last seen at Rollins Funeral Home where she had been attending a funeral. His vehicle was found in the head of Marrowbone Creek several days after he went missing. DeBerry disappeared within the same timeframe as his uncle Lynn DeBerry, whom he lived with and Dennis Powell. What got you interested in this case? 5. He was last seen around Eccles at approximately 1 a.m. the next morning. Witnesses said he was seen walking toward U.S. Route 52. If you know of a missing persons case not included in this list, please let us know below with the persons name, the details of the case and the agency leading the investigation. Sometimes, but I think as Sarah pointed out, there would be an abduction or some kind of event and it would get splashy news, and then when it actually got resolved, it was printed in a small story in the back of the newspaper, so people werent aware that there was a constant search for bad people doing bad things. June 25, 2021 at 9:00 a.m. EDT. West Virginia State Police say Adkins wife said he and at least three other men had gone to the sealed Upper Big Branch Mine to steal copper. Unsolved Cases - Kanawha County Sheriff's Office Unsolved Cases The Kanawha County Sheriff's Office works unsolved missing person and homicide cases to conclusion. So, 12 counts of attempted abduction, and he was put into psychiatric care for three months. We interviewed our tech expert, Jaime Vazquez, to learn more about accessible smart home devices. GF: He also said that he thought he would be let loose if he was not convicted in Morgantown. You have permission to edit this article. According to the report, Shannon Bartz ran to a corner, picked up a shotgun and began trying to hit her father with the butt end of the gun. Investigators said Kinker allegedly admitted to shaking the child in his bassinet because he was crying, saying it caused his head to strike the wall. A West Ashley High School football player, Mikell McKelvey . Across the state and in Mercer, McDowell and Monroe counties, troopers started looking at unsolved murders and disappearances. On December 8, 1963, a group of amateur criminals hoping to strike it rich engineered one of the most infamous kidnappings in American history. Can you bring your vape pen or e-cigarette on a plane? Tamperproof seals exist because of a 1982 spree, in which someone slipped cyanide into stores' Tylenol bottles, killing seven. 19 year old Nancy Santamero and 26 year old Vicki Durian had been hitchhiking from Welloman Iowa to Pocahontas county West Virginia to attend their first Rainbow gathering; a counter culture peace celebration. On Feb. 3, 1972, Bryce Durham, 51, his wife Virginia, 44, and their son Bobby, 18, were found murdered in their home during a snowstorm. Two cold case murders in Maryland and Virginia that took place about 15 years apart have been solved after an already incarcerated man confessed to both, according to police in Maryland. But, someone had written these letters saying that they wanted to help them find the bodies, and here was a map. Wilson sentenced Barnhart to 50 years in prison after taking guilty pleas on one count of second degree murder and two counts of wanton endangerment. Q: Do you think you had that perspective because you were a man as opposed to a woman in the 70s? Through the information we gained at that time and since then, we feel another party or parties were involved, First Sgt. She has not been seen since. The West Virginia State Police says Jones may be with a male named Jack Crone, the father of her child. Hamm was last seen at his cousins home in Dunlow in the early morning of March 4, 2015. Frank Sinatra, Jr., Kidnapping. More . Metheny was last seen dropping her children off at a daycare in the vicinity of the 3000 block of Dupont Avenue in Belle. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Clarden Rowen, Jr., who is also known as Bill or Buck was last seen at his home in Buckhannon around 1 p.m. to 1:30 p.m. Clarden has a scar on his right hand between his thumb and forefinger. The Story Of The Serial Killer Who Terrorized This Small West Virginia Town Is Truly Frightening No one in Clarksburg knew he was a serial killer and arsonist. On a darkening early evening, shortly before 5 p.m., on Saturday, Nov. 10, 1990, some hunters stumbled upon her skeletal remains in a cow pasture at Robinson Hollow near Barrackville. He seemed to know a lot about the case. She has multiple piercings as well as a tattoo of a sun on her right shoulder and a tattoo of a scorpion on her lower back. Here are six of the most vexing murder mysteries of all time: 1. Copyright News and Sentinel | https://www.newsandsentinel.com | 519 Juliana St., Parkersburg, WV 26101 | 304-485-1891, For every year that goes by, its another downer,, I hope he gets a conscience this year to bring peace to himself and peace to his family,, If theres a lead, well follow up on it,. Local police departments and county sheriffs departments also continue to seek new leads in their cold case investigations. Her cheating husband was not home at the time and saw her body through a window, before entering the home. Days later, on March 12, 2005, two young boys walking down East Street kicked that object, but did not realize what it was until it rolled down the incline. Aigeltinger was last seen at a Sheetz in Manassas Park, Virginia. There was a lot of child abductions. He would come to Morgantown. I put it on Reddits Unresolved and I met Kendall before I met Geoff, and we were standing on Kendalls porch, and I said, Hey, you just bought this house. Police identified a person of interest in the case, but no charges have been filed to date. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. If theres a lead, well follow up on it, he said. Local resident Jacob Beard was convicted of the murder in 1993, but he was later acquitted of all charges in a second trial in 2000. GF: There was another time that the magistrate fined the guy some small amount, 30 bucks or some kind of small amount of money for an assault. Dominique may have traveled to the Erie, Pennsylvania area. She will be tried as an adult for allegedly beating her father, Donald Bartz, 56, to death with the butt of a shotgun. The Oscars will air on ABC and can be streamed on ABC.com and the ABC app as well as Hulu + Live TV, YouTube TV, AT&T TV or FuboTV. Pettys remains were found in a burned out barn on a farm her father Marvin Petty owned off West Virginia 31. Published: Nov. 7, 2019 at 9:36 PM PST. John Brennan Crutchley is the person that I think is likely to have done it. SJM: [To Geoff] But what do you think is the most interesting part of the case? A flyer depicting the two persons of interest was generated at the time of the case. Photo courtesy: Putnam County Sheriffs Office. Some examples of unsolved child murders you can learn about in our fully visualized case files include the 1998 kidnapping and murder of Brittany Locklear, the 1997 murder of Georgia Lee Moses, the 2017 double-murder of Abigail "Abby" Williams and Liberty "Libby" German, and the 1960 murder of Nancy Eagleson. Pugh was last seen in a black two-door vehicle with an older white male. Worrell, a mother of two children, had been shot and killed. Crystal Cantrell, 36, of Welch, was last seen Aug. 6, 2010, on Gardner Road near Spanishburg with Michael Wiseman, according to an earlier report by retired First Sgt. Tulock sustained multiple gunshot wounds and died at the scene, apparently after attempting to intervene in a domestic dispute involving Barnhart and his girlfriend. More information on the WVU Coed Murders book and podcast is available on their website, coedmurders.com. Amber Saunders of Huntington - Last seen Aug 20, 2021 at 16 years old. We cant ignore them and we take them all seriously.. June 1973. West Virginia, USA. Sign up now to get our FREE breaking news coverage delivered right to your inbox. Welcome to the Virginia Cold Case Database This website was developed to assist Virginia State Police investigators and local law enforcement in soliciting tips on unsolved cases throughout the Commonwealth. Below is a list of missing persons cases in West Virginia that remain unsolved. The flyer said the men allegedly hotwired a 1985 Autocar with a double cab and step-in fully loaded with a Younger Brothers decal on the door that was stolen approximately 15 miles from the area where Sharp was found, or they could have also been driving a 1973-1974 red Cadillac with a white vinyl top. Nov 21, 2019 - Mysterious events from WV saved by Mark Legg of Harper, WV. See more ideas about mysterious events, west virginia, unsolved. She had been savagely murdered: shot in the head twice, neck fractured, face disfigured and powder-burned, throat cut from ear to ear. But, apparently, a lot of other state troopers didnt feel that way. You may opt-out anytime by clicking "unsubscribe" from the newsletter or from your account. Authorities believe Roop may have been abducted. He has a tattoo that reads ANS on his shoulder, a tattoo of the chemical structure of marijuana on his inner left arm and a tattoo of the Legend of Zelda Triforce symbol on his inner right arm. He has scars on his chin and the left side of his rib cage. - Christopher Devin Kinker, 21, of Follansbee is facing second-degree murder and child abuse charges after he allegedly killed his seven-week-old son. Friends of his were having a wedding. Authorities say he would regularly walk to his job. May was last seen on Little Egypt Road in Gilbert. Curry has a glass left eye and a tattoo of a cross on his left arm. According to police, her mother went to work on Aug. 20, 2019 and Cochran was nowhere to be found when she returned home, but all of her belongings were still there. Eventually the bodies were found eight, nine miles south of Morgantown rather than 25. 2500 Block of Arctic Avenue. SJM: Were very close to a stream and near the woods right now. A fatal 2004 pedestrian accident in Mercer County also remains unsolved. She did not take her belongings and expected to return home. Dennis was last known to be at his home Dec. 15, 2013, but has not been heard from since. Barki said the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals in December denied an appeal by Assistant Public Defender Bob Gaudio and appointed counsel Martin Sheehan asking that Bartz be tried as a juvenile. In our 3 part series, we will go back in time to resurrect 9 cold-case unsolved murders in the Mountain State. It was no longer a dorm, so there was no issue with the buses not being able to get out there because it wasnt a dorm anymore, but other than that, I cant say that a lot of safety precautions were taken. Man charged in 66-year-old man's cold case murder, Galveston PD says. The flyer also says he had a large beer gut and a tattoo on his right arm depicting a naked woman with a snake wrapped around her body.. He has a cross tattoo and a tattoo of the Pittsburgh Pirates P logo. Plentiful sunshine. It's been five years since the shooting death of Vienna resident Cindy Ball and many wonder why her case remains unsolved. Crutchley was investigated for the deaths and disappearances of 26 women in the DC/Maryland/Virginia/Pennsylvania area. We interviewed our tech expert, Jaime Vazquez, to learn more about accessible smart home devices. That wasnt really a thing, so the police would always have to cobble together the things, but thats a whole lot less than ideal. There was a lot of people doing bad things, especially to women in Morgantown. Contact your local law enforcement agency to file a missing persons report. GF: I shadowed a state trooper, Lieutenant Colonel Richard Hall, back in 2006 to 2009 or 2010, and he was investigating the case. I think its fair to say we both dont think that he did it.