additionally I want to thank you for the great comparison and data on these tests. This will determine if the weight of the muzzle brake is one of the factors in the effectiveness of one at reducing recoil. There is nothing mechanical about the function of the firearm that causes the muzzle to go up. Im looking to prevent the fast fire AK style of muzzle rise. Fortis Control w/ Black Muzzle Brake Bundle Pack The Fortis Control Shield was designed to push the noise forward for combative situations or even for simple range use, while the top ports keep the muzzle device flat on target. Keeping the gun still means the sights stay right on target (or get progressively closer to staying on target as you reduce more and more recoil), allowing for faster, more accurate shooting. Will you be doing a video on the Surefire Warcomp CTN, the birdcage style of the Warcomp? I have not found myself surprised by my real-word perception of felt recoil not aligning with results of the sled testing. LANTAC 5.56 Dragon Dead Air KEYMO Wolfman Muzzle Brake. BCMGUNFIGHTER 5.56 Compensator BCM is high-quality, and the exterior dimensions of this nitride-treated compensator are consistent with mil-spec for mounting flash hider mounted suppressors. Theyre very effective if you are fortunate enough to have an AR capable of full-auto fire. Length:2.25 We found in Flash Hiding Test #2 that its about 37% brighter than an A2, which is asignificant flash reduction vs. a bare muzzle, and in this test we see that it cuts recoil almost in half, putting the A2 to shame. Round ports at a ~45 angle to the round bore makes for an interesting internal shape where port and bore meet to create baffle, and it certainly seems to work. Its made by Troy Industries, and is meant to be a good all-around unit functioning as a brake and a comp while keeping flash to a minimum. Length:2.44 Im betting that some of the comps that didnt do so well in the pure recoil tests will be found to be more effective where it counts : muzzle control. Dead/ Bad Links WeaponTech Punisher Compensator/Flash Hider Is there another combo that you recommend that is as effective? . Finish:machined copper (as tested), also available Cerakoted, nitrided, and other finishes depending on metal Your brakes look cool and work very well. If you believe theres a 1:1 connection, then that doesnt account for the SJCs 4.15% better recoil reduction performance (and Id highly suggest looking at it as a percentage, not a distance measurement in inches). Material: steel Denver. Actually, you dont have to imagine it, because these sorts of muzzle devices do exist, and are becoming more and more popular with shooters. This bad boy landed in third place, providing a whopping 72.93% reduction in recoil. One thing though. Brakes on ARs are just obnoxious on the range. A flash hider works by rapidly cooling and then dispersing expelled gas, or redirecting the gases that exit the muzzle upon firing. The packaging states a 62% recoil reduction vs. an A2 birdcage (which we have shown to reduce recoil by a few percent compared to a bare muzzle), and I found a 68.5% reduction vs. a bare muzzle. I am considering the Dragon and BMD combo since it seems Lantac engineered the BMD to maintain the Dragons excellent performance. As an engineer I know that theory, no matter how seemingly airtight, sometimes does not stand against empirical results. (Im aware it would most likely require threading at least some of the barrel end.). Netting a 62.7% recoil reduction in a tiny, lightweight package means Im definitely a fan. I doubt there would be much if any swapping of ranks (1st, 2nd, 3rd, 10th, etc.). Let me know when youre doing another test I will dismount a couple from my rifles and send them out to you for testing. Blast/wind seems about the same, although it may have just a hair more concussion if youre off to the side. For more on the design features, seethis video. WeaponTech Punisher Compensator/Flash Hider: The WeaponTech Punisher Comp/Flash Hider, sold via Primary Arms (and designed by the same guy who created the ACSS scope reticle, which I absolutely love), is a novel combination of brake, comp, and flash hider. I can tell you that if you look here (https://oag.ca.gov/sites/all/files/agweb/pdfs/firearms/regs/fsor.pdf), starting in the middle of Page 2, youll see how the final definition came to be and what the thought process was behind it. [1] [2] 1175 - Munich gains official status as city. MSRP:$89.99. Finish:Cerakote (or similar) Wrench flats! Diameter(at largest point): 0.866 Have you tested these two in your previous reviews? Quanto mais tempo o avio voar, maior ser o multiplicador de sua aposta. The limited tests Ive proposed are about as empirical as it gets when it comes to testing the ACTUAL effectiveness of these devices in doing what we REALLY want them to achieve: Keeping the muzzle down during strings of fire. Sporting a proven design, these brakes redirect most of the gasses out to the side ports for reduced felt recoil. VG6 Epsilon + CAGE Device Length:2.752 I also prefer completely neutral brakes like your brakes, which I mentioned in various places in this article, as muzzle rise isnt an inherent feature of the AR but is due to the shooter to varying degrees. Held to the strictest standards, XTS products are manufactured from only the highest quality materials and are backed by some of the most generous manufacture warranties in the industry. MSRP:$89.95. For the record, I used a Precision Armament thread adapter to thread the 5/8-24 suppressor onto my 1/2-28 rifle. Dead/ Bad Links Tufforce Muzzle Brake with 4-side Picatinny Rail At least on the first shot in a string, as both of them get significantly less fiery becoming basically equivalent on subsequent shots. Material: Inconel I did do two flash hiding tests, in which many muzzle brakes and comps and hybrid devices appeared, so Id definitely suggest checking those out (theyre linked in the 2nd paragraph of this article). Moving on from flash hiders Are you looking for a muzzle device that assists in reducing upward lift or muzzle flip when firing? The Dirty Bird .30 5/8-24 A2 Birdcage Flash Hider is the classic A2 flash hider design but refined in key areas. I wasnt familiar with 2111 Arms prior to coming across this comp, and Im glad that I did. http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/firing-ar-15-horrifying-dangerous-loud-article-1.2673201. Jeremy. This can be very helpful when firing off shots in rapid succession. The only way to buy is Muzzel Brake pined & welded ? If you are planning on doing another brake review, we would like to send you one of ours for your testing. How did you get yours? Ill just be fighting it and having to pull the muzzle back up to target with my support hand. NBS Tanker This budget-friendly tanker-style muzzle brake features all-steel construction with a heat treated, erosion resistant black nitride finish. I do not foresee a muzzle brake test where I focus on suppressor-accepting brakes. Id love to see a comparison of brakes + blast shields, including the aforementioned Indian Creek Device (with several different brakes): Lantac Dragon + Blast Mitigation Device As a relatively plug-and-play muzzle device for your AR-15, this is certainly on our personal short list. Ill have to read through every word: the video was fascinating. Great information, thank you. The Titan is larger and heavier than the M4-72, but breathes less fire. Ill admit muzzle brakes definitely have their merits in competitive shooting where youre trying to scrub milliseconds off your stage times, but thats also an environment where you arent literally ruining the experience of everyone around you. Precision machined in the USA and backed by the NBS limited lifetime warranty, these are possibly the best value muzzle brake on the market. Machining and finish are excellent. Well the A2 is a flash hider, as you stated. Read ALL of these tests repeatedly. Were that sled results do not equate perfectly to shoulder results Id agree with you across the board, especially if were pointing out that a lot of it has to do with subjective vs. objective rather than trying to say the sled is flawed, which I dont believe is a fair implication at all. Its a very clean piece. Muzzle Device Questions? Im currently testing a universal blast shield from Indian Creek Design called the Blast Forwarding Device (http://www.indiancreekdesigninc.com/). Jeremy, great information and I liked that you did start mentioning about the side blast from some of these compensators. Apparently they dont realize that the height of this rail is way lower than AR rail height, and it would be basically impossible to jury rig a sight onto this thing at a usable height. This is another brake with no wrench flats, but Lilja sells a tool for torquing it down via one of the ports. Another user who can benefit from a flash hider is someone in law enforcement who is looking to attenuate muzzle flash to protect their night vision. There is also a non-extended 3.25 version available, as well as a micro that measures 1.75 long. The sniff test is basically 1) is there any mention of flash reduction in the company materials and 2) does it clearly have recoil-reducing design features. Expect a meaningless (~5%) reduction of recoil from it. Weight:2.665 oz I think I may have forgotten that I didnt affix it previously. rosie rivera house address 4123; kal magnesium glycinate arsenic; is captain jacks deadbug safe; doctors accepting new patients whitby Diameter(at largest point): 1.014 It tremendously reduces felt recoil and its tip reduces ground effects when shooting prone. Ive been very excited to recoil test this flash hiding compensator since it nearly won Flash Hiding Test #2, despite nottechnically being just a flash hider. Best. I think its safe to say at this point that Muzzle Brake Shootout #4 is never happening. Not much, but enough to notice and to be relatively confident of it. In most muzzle devices that vent more gas/pressure upwards than downwards in order to effect a downwards force on the muzzle, itll be too much force for some shooters and too little for others. The M4-72 is smaller and lighter than the Titan, but it also spits more fire. Weight:1.67oz That said, if youre diving into the world of competition shooting, where youre needing to rip off fast, accurate strings of fire and not wanting to deal with a rifle climbing on you, a compensator just might be the muzzle device for you. But for most ARs? Which, as you may note, was two years ago. Each muzzle device was timed properly, and tested twice. As with everything Ive seen from Precision Armament, machining and finish are industry-leading. Thats a 4 year old design if I am not mistaken. This 3-port muzzle brake is compatible with the Specwar 5.56 and 7.62, and Harvester Big Bore/Omega ASR mounting system. Maybe in the future you could do a battle of the cheapos, $50 or less, if someone else hasnt already. Kind of added insult to injury. Seems that most other shield systems degrade performance once the shield is applied. Diameter(at largest point): 0.852 Faster follow-up shots when hunting? No one online seems to have any. .223/5.56 Muzzle Brake; Black Nitride Finish; 1/2X28 Thread Pitch; One Crush Washer Included Well talk about those near the end of this article. Here are the results: SJC Titan Comp. Material: 17-4PH stainless steel New price $94 ODIN Works ATLAS 5 Comp Although it is simply a cosmetic issue, thread protectors really are not all that attractive. although, now that Im looking at the photograph again (the brake went to Tyler Kee for use with his TBAC cans), it appears as though one of the suppressor mounting threads is squished, Material: steel And that isnt just eliminating the downwards force, its turning it into upwards force and essentially doubling the effect. Absolutely top-notch. New price $56.95 Apex Tactical Enhanced Stabilization Attachment Its never made it into the field because I like to be able to hear what goes on around me and Im too cheap to buy electronic ear pro. June 14, 2022; pros and cons of stem cell therapy for knees . Pop this on an NFA lower with a three round burst mech. Im impressed. A good brake on a rifle pushing a big projectile is a good thing, just not for the audience around you, unless of course there is something used to mitigate the thump. Its also how its applied could be a very quick, sharp impulse and could be more of a push over time. Although I dont yet have access to professional dB metering equipment to test volume level claims, I figured the same gas-trapping principals were likely to lead to a change in recoil reduction. MSRP:$235.99. However, its not something wed ever just toss on the front of our firearm without thought. so, like when are you going to provide any detail? FWIW I think its fair to say that 13 of the 20 brakes that reduced recoil in this test by more than the Kahntrol brake have either no design feature whatsoever or have only very limited design features creating downwards force. Forum Rules and FAQ; Calendar; Forum Actions. Length:1.808 With so many ARs, however, Im reminded of that old tale of the incompetent tailor with a glib tongue: upon picking up their suit, a customer realizes that it doesnt even remotely fit, but the tailor convinces the customer to hunch over like so, hike up his left arm into the sleeve by three inches, twist a little bit to the right, walk in a half-step and presto! These tests are expensive, but Id love to do more. Nord Arms is a competition-focused rifle parts company out of Estonia. It would probably be more helpful to recoil reduction test a bunch of popular suppressors, actually, rather than what they mount to. Good for being nice to neighbors on the range. The WARCOMP is primarily a flash hider a pretty good one, at that but it adds a blast baffle / expansion chamber with circular ports to provide muzzle rise compensation and recoil reduction. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. When I went to a featureless lay out, I had to ditch my A2. Diameter(at largest point): 1.02 The black oxide finish was done very well. I realize theres A LOT of text in this article, but it did include: Note: there is no comparison whatsoever between the inch measurements in this test and those in the previous 5.56 tests (or the .30 cal test). A hybrid device that has either advertised flash suppressing properties or functionally has flash suppressing properties would be deemed a flash suppressor. Length:2.373 It is designed to have much less side blast and noise associated with typical compensators. One of Venoms big claims to fame is manufacturing their brakes in various metal options. They do redirect the blast, concussion, and sound forward but I dont have the equipment to quantify any of that. The result is faster target acquisition on follow-up shots. core15 muzzle brake. I may do that. Length:2.355 Finally, while we prefer suppressors for hunting coyotes and hogs at night, when that is not an option, having an effective flash hider as a muzzle device on your AR is also a good idea. Hiperfire HIPERCOMP 5.56C Hiperfire is a name that is absolutely huge in the world of competitive shooters. BCM A2X Flash Hider BCM is known for quality and their muzzle devices like this flash hider are no exception. Thinking about the Ti version for pin and weld to a 14.5 barrel. So, yes, its definitely possible that peoples subjective opinions of more/less recoil will not perfectly align with these objective test results. Finish: Melonite QPQ Weight:2.796 oz It just seems like a company would realize that kinda thing is problematic before they start marketing it. MSRP:$67. Also, note that we are not covering suppressors here, which in a perfect world, are perhaps the ideal muzzle device if you have the ability to legally attain. All stated weights and dimensions are as measured by me. Tactical Advantage Armory NT-23 Titanium Muzzle Brake: The NT-23 is more than 4 inches of fish scale-lookin shark teeth with ports everywhere. 1) Add extra weight at or near the end of the barrel of one of the lightweight muzzle brakes so the AR-15 weighs the same as it does when a better performing heavier muzzle brake is installed. In this test, we find that it reduces recoil by almost 50%. Its pleasant to shoot, although its the same on all four sides so it could kick up dust pretty well from prone. Its a little more than a thread protector, but it aint a silencer all the blast goes forward. Finish:black Thank you. No Change Phase 5 FATman Hex Brake MSRP:$135.99 in titanium (not available in stainless). Thats about what most AR furniture is to gun fitting. That said, there are also muzzle devices that do not fit into these categories. Good job as always, but you need to remind your readers that sled results do not equate to shoulder results. Material: steel I could not agree more. And Im pretty sure that I remember reading the juggerbrake review. I did a scatter plot of recoil vs. price. Length:2.246 Id expect the percentage reduction numbers to change a bit but the muzzle devices to rank the same way compared to each other. Increase sight radius and such. Finish:salt bath nitride MSRP:$224.99. Mass is a legitimate way to reduce recoil and it absolutely is a factor. Weight:2.25 oz Length:2.314 There are no wrench flats on this brake, so a screwdriver went through one of the circular % sign holes to good effect. For the budget-conscious builder who is just putting together a simple AR build, an inexpensive but functional muzzle device like a flash hider certainly fits the bill. Dont make muzzle brakes for centerfire rifle calibers from aluminum!) I felt that way because those three, round ports always appeared in photos as though they were simply drilled through the brake perpendicular to the bore. At least prior to testing them it was my opinion that they were made to look cool and really nothing else, but it turns out they all performed admirably. The full size 2 port brake was my actual point of contention with the Paladin being referred to as an inferior compromise that still performs somewhat even on on a 16 308. You might also feel a slight reduction in recoil, depending on the compensator, but again, thats not necessarily the intended effect. I might whine if it were my receiver, but I think the level of attention and care is totally fine for a muzzle brake. It produces strong, shockingly-repeatable results at very lost cost and complexity, but perfect it is not. Material: heat treated ordnance steel I wont be feeding it hundreds of rounds in a session. Muzzle rise on an AR only happens because of rearwards recoil. ontario teacher pay grid 2020; maesteg railway tunnel; buying vietnamese dong at chase bank I have read all of the tests and I appreciate all the great information as I like to read a lot before making any purchases for my rifles. This compensator features a robust, cast design that is ideal for 3-gunners. I was simply suggesting doing a test or two to see how much of a factor it is. It would suggest that all of the immense testing you already did might be inconclusive and possibly reopen the issue. @Dyspeptic- Put me down for a signed copy of the book, Im a believer, and agree 100%. The King-Comp is a great alternative if youre looking for a cross between a compensator and a muzzle brake or effective combo muzzle device. Diameter(at largest point): 0.864 In addition, we also see blast deflectors, which are simple concussion-reducing muzzle devices that push blast out and away from the shooter, making for a better overall experience at the range. The J-COMP concept comes from the Type 89 Japanese assault rifle used by the Japan Self-Defense Forces, the Japan Coast Guards Special Security Team units, and the Special Assault Team. My 20 wears a KAW linear comp and noticeably reduces concussion and noise at the shooters ear and spectators to the sides. I suppose a strap wrench would be the way to install this guy as, again, there are no wrench flats but also really no other appropriate feature to exploit for torquing purposes (I may have shoved the shaft of a screwdriver in the muzzle teeth). core15 muzzle brake. The second mag of full-auto is going to show a damn steady AR no matter whats on the muzzle, IMHO, with a good shooter. On the subject of flash reduction, an observation With a given rifle, independent of muzzle device, the visible flash typically varies from shot to shot. I just wish it didnt get dirty so fast from shooting with it. New From Remington: Rp9 Full Size Polymer Pistol.